The essay that solved a painful recurring paradox
Throughout my location independent journey, I’ve been struggling with a question: how do I balance where I’m from, with where I’m at? With Europe in such a decline, and especially Finland being so far down a dark path that living in my home country is not even a consideration – did that mean that should I try to become something I perhaps am not, something that I haven’t been, and try to forget and diminish where I’m from?
That didn’t feel right.
Even though I didn’t yet know to put it in those words, what I needed to do was to figure out the relationship and correct balance between cosmopolitanism and patriotism.
I felt I was neither, and yet I was both – for years, it felt like quite a paradox indeed, and it bothered me. Then again, paradoxes are a great way to gain deep insight into the nature of reality, if they can be resolved.
It was Georgian writer Vazha-Pshavela that solved this paradox for me, and so I took up Vazha-Kareli (more on the Kareli-part later) as my pen name to honor him and his home country of Georgia. It is a Christian country surrounded by foreign threats on almost all sides, a country that has suffered even more than Finland has, but it always comes back victorious and stays true to its heritage.
Even if Europe falls (I don’t think that will happen, but many European countries are in danger), the European culture will have a safe haven in the mountain citadel of Georgia. I wish more of Europe was as proud of its culture as Georgia is, and I hope we can nudge it to that direction.
All cultures are not the same
Though that echoes the sentiment behind ‘Make Europe Great Again’, I’m not a huge fan of that meme. The MAGA movement, despite being critical about government, is still fully a statist ideology. However, the overarching European civilization used to be great, is great no longer, and holds the potential to be great once more – it just currently has this problem of “confused identity”, and is severely out of balance.
Currently, Europe doesn’t even recognize that there is something to balance – but Vazha-Pshavela did – way back in 1905, when he wrote his essay “Cosmopolitanism and Patriotism”. It starts with these powerful words:
“Some people think that true patriotism excludes cosmopolitanism. This is a mistake. Every true patriot is cosmopolitan and every genuine cosmopolitan is a patriot.”
I certainly don’t feel patriotic in the traditional way, in the blind, tribalistic and aggressive sense. I don’t get kicks when a Finnish sports team does well in some competition. Yes, technically they are “my people”, but what does that mean really? Personally, I just fail to see the point of such things – sorry.
At the same time, “full-on cosmopolitanism” makes equally little sense to me. Whenever I travel abroad, I normally feel quite distinct from the people in those other countries – sometimes very distinct. I am not them, and they are not “my people” – they are separate and different, despite the fact that we are still more alike than different. When I meet other Finnish people, I feel much more similar with them – we certainly share the same culture and see the other cultures through the same lens. Does that mean I should then be a patriot?
Perhaps not. I don’t feel particularly patriotic towards the current “version” of Finland I see. Yes, historically, Finland has been a great country, and Finnish people are a great nation of strong people – but when I look at what the country of Finland has now become, I see only shadows of past greatness.
I refuse to participate in the game of thievery...
We Finns like(d?) to think of ourselves as tenacious, humble people who take no pride in our mere existence, and instead find that pride in the results of our hard work - which, for centuries, was an obvious, non-negotiable prerequisite for that existence. Hence, we had very good reason to be proud of ourselves!
That pride wasn't something you were born with. It had to be earned through proof of work. Now, with the corrupting effect of the fiat economy and the democratic black hole (I explain that in my book), I see the once-great Finnish culture quickly degrading into a complete opposite of what it used to be. Too many Finns of today seem to feel entitled to all the riches of the world just through their "merit" of happening to exist.
While the mechanisms of how this has happened are complex, the damage done by it is simple and obvious: around the year 2000, Finns and Swedes were roughly at the same level of wealth per capita. Fast forward just 25 years, and Finland has fallen far behind: during that time 700 billion (in USD) of new wealth has materialized in Sweden, but not in Finland. In a country of 5 million, that's a big deal: that is over 120 000€ per person! This single, inescapable fact blasts a deafening warning: whatever is going on in Finland isn't working.
To me it's fully obvious why this is happening: when you know that the vast majority of the wealth you create will be forcefully confiscated by the state, you don't bother to create it in the first place. Finns have gone from being hardworking people to doing just the minimum to survive, and with the ever-increasing welfare benefits, for far too many that "minimum" means choosing not to work - even if they could find a job!
In this "new Finnish culture", working hard has been replaced by competing for who gets the quickest and biggest access to money taken from others. "Non-governmental" (lol!) organizations are leading, with the full backing of the government, and very little resistance from the people.
In order to preserve our culture (any culture!), we have to reclaim the ability to make moral judgements. We should have the courage to call even indirect theft as what it is: stealing. How - and even why - it is performed, matters very little.
I refuse to participate in a society where the game is for everyone to steal as much as they can from everone else. These Finns (that are not all Finns) have forgotten to consider a simple fact of life: crime doesn't pay - even if it's legal.
That crime has now cost Finland that 120 000€ per person - and counting, at an increasing pace! The participants (and voters) of this competitive thievery, whether they fully understand the game they're playing or not, are not my people. I don't care if they happen to have the same passport or even if they speak the same language.
I owe zero allegiance to thieves.
I am extremely patriotic in a cultural sense – I think the Finnish culture is truly great and through many objective metrics, it really is one of the best cultures in the world. It needs to be cherished, preserved and developed further. It deserves to be kept alive.
The western self-loathing is killing us
As the very opposite of that, in contemporary Finland I see mostly just the corrosive versions of cosmopolitanism and globalist ideals. The state is force-feeding us ideologies that are very destructive to the true national spirit and the strength of the nation and its culture. This is exactly what Vazha-Pshavela warns about:
“The person who negates their country while labelling themselves cosmopolitan is maimed by illusions. Even though this person may present themselves as a lover of the noblest feelings, such a person is unconsciously an enemy of humanity.”
That’s just chillingly accurate. The globalist ideals are wreaking havoc in Europe, as our so called “elites” are destroying our societies (in reality, they are just parasites and have nothing to do with “elite”). Through their endless self-loathing, they see every other culture as superior, wanting to destroy their own – whether they do so unconsciously or knowingly, the end result doesn’t change.
Perhaps this false cosmopolitanism can be described with another name: internationalism. I’m not sure if they are 1:1 the one and the same, but the problems seem to be the same. Whatever you call it, Vazha-Pshavela continues:
“May God protect us from this pseudo-cosmopolitanism, which would require everyone to deny their place of birth. This kind of cosmopolitanism means rejecting one’s very self.”
This madness must stop.
True diversity instead of grey mass monoculture
I wish to see the world as truly, literally “multi cultural”, meaning that there should be multiple different cultures. The cultures don’t stay different unless they are allowed to develop in their own separate areas. Currently in the world, there are around 200 of such areas, called “countries”.
I’d prefer to see at least 10 000 different areas, each with their own flavors of different, separate and distinct cultures – with active, positive and voluntary interaction between them. That would be true cultural richness, unlike the grey mass monoculture we’re being told we must conform with.
Having all of those different areas doesn’t even require “dismantling” the current system of countries, as it might be enough to just have more independence among the different areas within those. Unlike some destructive ideologies, we don’t need to tear down the old to build something new.
The essay ends:
“Every nation seeks freedom and the means to rule itself independently. The separate development of nations is the condition for the development of all humanity.”
Never have truer words been written! Thank you, Vazha-Pshavela!
This story doesn’t end here…
This isn’t a simple name. To uncover everything it means, the story takes a turn into what felt like a surreal, dystopian alternate reality. From there I continue by further exploration of my uneasy relationship with modern Finland, and trace back my ancient bloodline right to the center of Karelian and Finnish history.
My roots and the surreal wealth gap cutting Karelia in two
Vazha-Pshavela means “a son of (people/region of) Pshavi”. I’m not a son of Pshavi, but a son of Karelia, which in history has been an area divided in two, an area of a Finnish subculture that has always existed between two countries. I was lucky to be born on the Finnish, not the Soviet side of that area.
Boring grammar notes, feel free to skip!
I’m aware that in Georgian, the word “Pshavela” is grammatically correct way to refer to someone from Pshavi. In order to refer to someone from Karelia correctly, it would be “Kareleli”. However, as I will use this name with English speakers, with my current legal names I’ve learned that complexity does come with some cost. Simple is better, so I shortened the name a bit – it still works and carries the same meaning.
Another difference is that Vazha-Pshavela wasn’t a “last name” (it was his full pen name), unlike how I’m using Vazha-Kareli. I wanted to maintain the connection to my given name Jaakko. On that note, I’ve considered changing that to the form of Yaakko to save myself from having to go through the pronunciation with everyone, but that idea started to feel too much like butchering the name.
Jaakko is a traditional Finnish name, and I’ll just keep it that way. It’s not the easiest first name for English speakers to pronounce or write (misspellings outnumber correct ones more than 10x). Just know that it’s pronounced like Yaakko – and yes, you don’t need to be able to pronounce the double consonant correctly, I forgive you 😉
Also, a Georgian town/municipality named Kareli exists. That is coincidental and I have no particular affiliation with that region. I’ll certainly visit there on my next trip to Georgia though!
I remember going to the now ex-Soviet side for the first time in the late 1990s with my dad. It wasn’t my first trip abroad (I remember having visited at least West Germany with my mom and brother) but was still one of the first countries I visited, and it felt like going to another world – but not in a good way. The wealth gap on that border was greater than in the border between US and Mexico.
It was quite literally a surreal experience.
Teleporting to the real-world dystopian movie set
The post-Soviet side was completely devastated, and I hear in many ways still is (I haven’t visited Russia since then). Just a 20 kilometer drive from my home, it was like teleporting from a 1st world country straight into the 3rd world. It felt like being in a movie set, made to reflect some strange dystopian alternate reality.
The “Karelian Republic” is apparently one of the poorest provinces even within Russia, and outside Moscow, it’s not exactly a rich country anywhere. During the 90s, along with all of Russia, it was really at its knees – strongly competing for the lowest point in the history of low points!
I remember two things from that trip: the visible poverty and devastation everywhere, and the absolutely delicious meatballs we had in a restaurant in Sortavala (the nearest town right after the border). I don’t know why I remember those meatballs so vividly. Perhaps it was the extreme contrast between everything being in shambles, and then still having probably the best meatballs I’d ever had. I guess life always finds a way?
I’m anti-interested in trying to fix the Soviet Union(s)
Karelia is a very interesting historical A/B experiment: same geography, same people (although the Soviets did shuffle that deck quite a bit), mostly all the same variables except governance. A mere 60 years before, the areas had been essentially the same (Finland lost that part of Karelia to the Soviet Union in the wars of 1939-1944). Now, having seen the utter destruction with my own eyes, well, it was definitely an eye-opener!
Communism kills, literally and directly. Socialism kills perhaps in more indirect ways, but trying to apply it in capitalist countries is pushing them into the same poverty as those left standing after communism. This is the sad direction we’re seeing now in Europe and the UK.
The results of the Karelian A/B test are not in any way unclear, and neither are any other results of any socialist “tests”. Because of that, the European “leaders” either know exactly what they’re doing – or they should know. Being somehow unaware of these things should prevent anyone from holding any power over others, but of course I’m aware that’s not how the current system works.
Therefore I choose to withdraw my support of the current system, because that’s all I can do. Doing anything else would be like trying to “support” the Soviet Union – it was effectively based on the same ideology, worked just as poorly, and you could (in practical terms) do just as little to try to “fix it”.
I couldn’t imagine more depressing waste of time than trying to come up with plans to make either of these monsters somehow “work better”!
Finnish culture is superior and needs to be preserved
I’m quite proud of my Karelian Finnish roots. I’m not sure if I count myself as a part of the “tribe of Karelians” (the distinct meaning of that has mostly disappeared and fused with the general Finnish culture after the Winter War). I consider myself more Finnish than “Karelian”, but that distinction matters fairly little – what matters is the culture. Whether Karelian or some other Finnish subgroup, the Finnish culture is distinctly and objectively better than, as an example, some actually tribal native culture.
It is that way because in Finland, for a millennia, the deal was that either you worked very hard and planned far into the future, or you starved to death – plain and simple. It was still more or less that way even when my parents were born. There’s even a saying “sen joka ei töitä tee, ei syömänkään pidä.” (Those who don’t work, don’t get to eat).
All of that has made for a pretty solid culture that gets things done and doesn’t get discouraged because of slight setbacks. A culture that has true sisu, a single short word in Finnish, that can only be translated to English through long paragraphs (which you won’t find here).
Different cultures produce different results, and Finnish culture has produced world-class results in the past, literally driving humanity forward. It can do so again, even if the current country of Finland chooses to suppress that drive for ideological reasons.
Even if the current country of Finland is dead set on a path of false cosmopolitan internationalist self-destruction, it is the original culture of Finland that matters, and what should be preserved.
The ancient bloodline at the heart of Karelian history
This slightly tenuous relationship with the actual “tribe of Karelia” was holding me back a bit when I was just considering using this name. Even though there are no external limitations to what names I can choose to use, taking up a new name is still not something I wanted to take lightly. This is a name I plan to use in public contexts, and it would become a part of me.
Even though I am originally from Karelia (the Finnish Province of North Karelia to be precise), I questioned whether that was really enough of a reason to use it as a part of my name – after all, I hadn’t even lived there in decades. I was wondering whether basically my family roots and childhood was sufficient reasoning (even if none was really needed) of now taking that up as an actual part of my name. There is a lot of history (and present) with Karelia overall, and the more I learned about it, the more distant my relationship with it all was starting to feel.
It was from distance that I found my final reason – not geographical distance, but distance in time. In fact, this reason was from hundreds of years back.
The Swedish Finnish Russian diplomat, warrior and adventurer
I was reading a biography of one of my forefathers (great-x5-grandfather to be precise), Count Gustaf Mauritz Armfelt, a Finnish-Swedish (and technically Russian) diplomat, warrior and an adventurer. Three “nationalities” instead of just one is very telling – his life was pretty wild! He lived at the turn of the 19th century (1757-1814). It was a tumultuous period, especially for Finland, and he was active during a major turning point in Finnish history.
In 1809, Sweden lost a war with Russia. As a result, the whole not-yet-independent region known as Finland changed “ownership” from being a province of the Kingdom of Sweden, to becoming a Grand Duchy of the Russian Empire – hence the technical, not really cultural “Russian” nationality of Gustaf Mauritz (it’s noteworthy that in his dealings with the Emperor, they apparently spoke French, not Russian).
Gustaf Mauritz was Finnish, and one of the strongest power players in the creation of what ultimately became independent Finland.
He was a true cosmopolitan and a patriot.
The abolition of serfdom in a 19th century special economic zone
To cut a very long story short, Karelia is situated in the border area between Finland and Russia, and the exact border has changed many times over the centuries. In a few different wars in the previous century, Sweden had lost many areas of Karelia to Russia. Now, with the annexation of Finland to Russia, the question of “Old Finland” (mostly the Karelian areas) came under new consideration.
Emperor Alexander I had some libertarian ideas – and if you know anything about the history of Russia, this was “atypical” to say the least. Together with his now close and trusted advisor Gustaf Mauritz they wanted to make Old Finland a part of the greater Finland (which had just become an autonomous province of Russia). The idea was to use that area as “testbed” for possibly getting rid of serfdom (“land slavery”), which was common in all of Russia, but not practiced in Finland.
That idea didn’t sit well with the powerful Russian nobility, who obviously benefited greatly from their effective slave ownership. Gustaf Mauritz knew that the nobility would try to fight back with regulations and red tape, much like the bureaucrats of today (I see a lot of similarities with Musk’s (now unfortunately failed) attempts to bypass bureaucracy via DOGE – both understood the importance of swift measures!).
With some direct action, he might be able to circumvent the bureaucratic bog that the nobility was planning to bury this plan into – but by acting quickly and directly with the Emperor, there was a real chance that these Karelian areas could be once again made part of Finland.
Individual actions can alter the course of history
Before reading his biography, I had absolutely no idea that the history of Karelia was this intricately linked to my family history. In fact, the way history is taught in Finnish schools, I was under the impression that the part of Karelia in question had always been a part of Finland. Not that it was actively taught to have been, but more like that part of history was just too distant to cover in detail in school, while the area losses in the 2nd World War were more recent and relevant.
The historicity of this opportunity wasn’t lost on Gustaf Mauritz, and he was fully aware of how important this could be. In the end, the plan did succeed, and the larger Viborg area of Karelia did officially become a part of Finland, and stayed that way from 1812 until it was lost again in the wars of 1939-1944.
While it would be inaccurate to say that Gustaf Mauritz “single-handedly” made this significant part of Karelia into a part of Finland (things weren’t quite that simple even in the early 19th century!), it is also fair to say that it likely wouldn’t have happened without him.
His close personal ties with the Emperor certainly mattered a great deal. He became the “project leader” of a project that had powerful enemies, but he did manage to pull it through with the help of the Emperor, significantly affecting the history of Finland.
To me, the life story of Gustaf Mauritz is a reminder that history is a result of actions of people, and the individual choices and actions matter, and they can matter a lot.
Learning about his life and deeds sealed the deal for me with this name, to say the least. My history is deeply linked with Karelia, and I couldn’t imagine a better name for myself. Through centuries of history, I am a son of Karelia.
However, it wouldn’t be enough to just become Jaakko Karjalanpoika (which would be a Finnish version of this name – “Karjalan poika” translates directly as “Karelia’s son”).
A tree is more than its roots. Through my choices, I’ve grown beyond Karelia and Finland, and I’m equally proud of having done that.
I am a son of Karelia, and a son of the world. I am a cosmopolitan and a patriot.
I am Vazha-Kareli.
What about the solutions?
I’m not the kind of person who just whines about problems without at least trying to do something about them. The problems I’ve hinted at above are pretty serious and I don’t claim I have any ultimate solutions for them.
What I do have, is a set of tried and true methods of how you can minimize the effect of these issues on your own life, and how to build yourself up to withstand the havoc that these problems might be leading to. That’s the best I can do right now personally, and I think you can do it too – if you have the right framing and understanding of the problems & solutions.
That’s why I wrote a book.