A non-consumed consumption good
One of the best things about writing is that it allows you to hone and clarify your thinking. That has certainly been the case with these chapters on real estate.
At first, I was trying to frame the questionable investment nature of real estate as “consumption”, which felt logical at first because if you’re unable to sell your investment for true profit, it’s technically not inaccurate to then say it was consumption rather than investment.
Then again, that didn’t seem to fit right.
You don’t “consume” a house or an apartment (hopefully!). Some wear and tear will inevitably be caused, but is it “consumption”? Not really! With proper maintenance, real estate should stay as is, even if it is at the same time – in an economic sense – being used as a “consumer good”, ie. used for living or doing business in.
So, it’s incorrect to talk about consumption, but that doesn’t mean that “investment” was the best word to use. Investments are supposed to produce something, and houses don’t produce new houses; you have to consume and expend resources only to keep them as they are. But it’s still not consumption, despite consuming and not producing… tricky, huh?
Real estate through the lens of divestment instead of investment
In cases where a certain piece of real estate doesn’t (or shouldn’t realistically be expected to) produce a purchasing power profit, I think the correct word to use would be divestment. It means taking money away from other investments (which could at least be expected to be truly profitable) and parking it elsewhere. This word is often used when money is taken out of stocks and put into cash, often if a market downturn is expected.
I think that sounds about right: when you put money into fiat cash, it shouldn’t be expected to be a profitable move on average, but it can be if you have reliable information that the investment you had that money in might take a downturn. If you keep that money parked in cash indefinitely, then inflation will eat your purchasing power – but if you have better information than other market participants, divesting into cash temporarily can be a wise financial move.
With real estate divestment, the divestment logic is different of course, as inflation is generally expected to be “ingested” by the real estate market as a whole. Whether that’s “CPI inflation” or “M2 inflation” or “true purchasing power inflation” (none of these are exact measurements by any means) is not really relevant as the real world is messy. For the purposes of this high-level logic, let’s just agree that inflation is a non-factor when divesting into real estate.
If you then look at the other costs of real estate, well, that depends on your use of that property. If you’re using it as “true” investment property, i.e. renting it out, then it can be expected that you should be able to fit all those other costs into the rent, and therefore consider them zeroed out. Of course it wouldn’t be a great investment property if the rent only covered costs, so add some margin on top – whatever the rental market allows.
Now, this all works out great in theory: you have no inflation to worry about, your maintenance and other costs are covered by the rent you’re receiving, and you’re also making some profit on top. Great?
Not so fast – that was only theory, and in the real world you’re now dealing with potentially annoying or outright problematic tenants who may or may not pay their rent in time or at all, things are breaking down every now and then, and you’re stuck with the responsibility of having them fixed. Being a landlord is rarely a full-time job, but it is definitely a job! Often the pay isn’t great (everything considered) and the people you get to work with may not be the best society has to offer. If you’re expecting that to not be messy, you might be in for a world of disappointment and financial loss. That probability is much bigger than zero.
As we discussed in the previous chapters, a good property manager can help with a lot of that, but now you’re having to pay some or even all of that profit to someone else – so you’ve perhaps only parked your money in what can reasonably be expected to be an inflation-free divestment, but any profit is now questionable.
Even with the above, you’re also still the one carrying the full weight of all the risks, and you should calculate the full cost for those. If you’re fully or even over-insured and were able to include that insurance cost in the rent, you might think you’re covered – but what about the tenant risk? Can you get insurance against nightmare tenants? Probably not! Don’t forget to consider a price to all uninsured risks.
For all of those reasons, skipping the tenants completely might seem like a tempting idea to those who can afford to do so: use that dwelling part-time for living while you’re in that country, and keep it empty the rest of the time.