My personal experiences of the insane real estate transaction costs
One of the issues that has been bugging me about real estate for a long while is the insane size of the transaction costs. Whenever a piece of real estate changes hands, the cut taken by “third parties” is quite sizable, easily going far into a double-digit percentage!
Knowing that these deals are usually quite pricey, I do wonder where that money actually goes and how much work is really done by those third parties to earn it.
A real-life example: When I sold my apartment in Kuopio, Finland, I remember paying the real estate agent over 3,000€. It was of course measured as some percentage of the deal. I wondered about this amount of money, because at the time my own monthly wage was less than that (yes, it’s quite normal for Europoors even in decent jobs to be paid so little).
Then I wondered how much work that agent had to do:
- To get my specific apartment selling gig – surely the total advertising cost can’t have been zero, but I don’t think the local real estate advertising market is so crowded that the ad costs would be driven very high. I would estimate this amount of work/cost as “low” (I might be wrong on that, but this isn’t hugely important for the big picture).
- To find a buyer – this is the main job and could be a fair bit of work, everything considered.
- To facilitate the paperwork – I think in this case the paperwork was very much standard, mostly ready from when I bought the place, and almost a copy-paste job.
To add all that up, I always wondered, and still do, whether that amount of work was more than what I did at the time at my normie IT job in a whole month?! And the agent was being paid more than this. Did her work then produce that much more value than my work?
Well, it’s possible, as she did get paid a fair market price and nobody held a gun to my head when I made that deal, so yes, technically she did earn that money fair and square! I’m not claiming the agent did anything morally wrong!
But here’s the thing: that’s a narrow view of “value”. When someone provides a correctly priced service of true, real value, you walk away with a feeling that you got even more than what you paid for (and may even get a feeling that next time you would gladly pay more!).
Do I have that feeling in this case, or in my other dealings with real estate agents? It’s pretty much the opposite. I feel like they get paid A LOT for what seems like not that much work!
Now, I do realize that in a situation like this, it is totally possible that I just didn’t see how much work the agent really did, and I don’t know their advertising costs. But then again… my >3000€ example is probably at a very low end of their rewards in general. Being frugal, I had originally bought pretty much the cheapest half-decent place I could find, and the agent’s reward was calculated as a percentage of the selling price, as is standard in the business.
Now, imagine if the price of the apartment had been double what it was. Would it have been double the amount of work to sell it? Of course not! Still, the agent’s pay is directly doubled. This is actually pretty insane and cannot in any way be described as being accurately rewarded for the value provided!
Things got even crazier when I made the mistake of thinking I’d like to buy a house in Panama. The price of the house was agreed to be something like $120k, with a down payment of about $20k. Long story short, I pulled out of the deal after paying the down payment, knowing that I would lose it. The seller told me that most of that money hadn’t even gone to him, but something like $14k was taken by lawyers just for the paperwork. Even taxes couldn’t have been a part of it, as the deal was never finalized.
Well over 10% of the intended price of the deal, just gone up in the air. Poof. Gone. Magic! Insane much?