Real estate and location independence
In a book about location independence, why write about something immovable like real estate? Aren’t nomads just supposed to live in Airbnb’s, or rent, and leave real estate investing to others?
Such thoughts may sound correct at first, but with any deeper scrutiny, real estate does sit at the heart of many of the questions around location independent lifestyle. In fact, many location independent people invest heavily into real estate and consider it one of the cornerstones and enablers of their nomadic lifestyle.
I’ve never really bought that idea.
Yes, at times I’ve heavily considered buying real estate, not for investment reasons, but purely for use. Now I’m past even that. Perhaps not forever and absolutely, but I just see so many downsides in it. The reasons why are a bit more complicated than just the traditional question about “should I rent or buy”. I think the whole idea of real estate investment (especially pure investment properties) isn’t something most people should be doing – location independent or not!
This will definitely be a very controversial topic, but one that I think especially nomadic people should give careful thought to. With a location independent lifestyle, there are more considerations – both pro and con – around this topic than with people with stationary lives. Therefore this topic, covered in depth, is squarely within the scope of this book.
I’m definitely not here to convince that you should never buy real estate – some of the questions around whether you should or shouldn’t are discussed in the chapter 9.4 Can real estate divestment be a good idea?. There are many reasons for putting money into real estate, and financial reasons are just one consideration. However, the finances around real estate are often grossly misjudged by most people, so let’s go through how I see the numbers playing out in a more fundamental sense.
Real estate and purchasing power
The reason why most people see real estate as an “always profitable” investment, is that they don’t fully understand the most important aspect of money: purchasing power.
Real estate goes up “in value” (when measured in fiat currency) but often doesn’t beat real inflation. Real inflation is different (higher, maybe about double in the US) from the fraudulent and heavily manipulated Consumer Price Index (CPI) measurement. Other countries vary, but all are worse off against the US over the long term, 10y+.

If your “investment” doesn’t beat real inflation, ie. the money you get out is worth less (in real goods and services) than what you put in, well, it wasn’t much of an investment! If you lose purchasing power, you’ve consumed rather than invested.
Under the fiat paradigm, people need to earn their money twice: first just to make it, and a second time to keep it. Saving in fiat isn’t an option because more money is printed all the time, which causes inflation to eat those savings. This makes (passive) stock investing so popular, but as that brings with it risks and volatility, real estate is seen by many as a more stable option. That might be all good in theory, but the messy reality can make this quite complicated.

True profitability of real estate is under constant threat
Investments ought to be profitable – in real terms, not just when measured against the CPI. I do not see real estate, on average, being a profitable investment.
Why not?
Let’s forget about money, finances etc. for a moment, and just focus on the “real economy” and fundamental physical facts.