Disclaimer: this is not tax advice, and is written by a tax non-professional
Same warnings apply here as in the previous chapter. I’m not a tax professional and might be wrong about everything here – this isn’t tax advice! What I describe here has kept me out of trouble with the tax officials of many different countries, but some (or all) of it might be just luck – do your own research and hire a real tax professional to review your plans!
Do NOT take risks with the tax authorities – if your plans are less than solid, they do have the means (and often also have the will) to ruin your life! Paying professional tax advisors is one of the best uses of money, even if it may not always feel necessary. When you do your homework properly, you don’t have to pay them huge sums of money to start from scratch – having them just check an already well thought out plan doesn’t have to be hugely expensive.
What tax planning shouldn’t be
Before we get into how you should plan for your taxes, let’s define what you shouldn’t be doing. There is a lot of bad advice in the internet on how to “dodge” taxes. If you start having to think deeply about specific letters of the law and where all kinds of different vague lines may or may not be, you’ve probably put yourself in some kind of legal grey area, and that’s never a great situation to be in.
If you have to discuss your business bookkeeping with the tax office, I really hope you’re doing so with the help of highly professional tax advisors who’ve been able to predict such discussions 100% beforehand. If you need to fight with the tax office about vague limits, definitions and interpretations, in my mind your plan has already failed and you’re in damage control mode (which may fail, catastrophically).
The whole point of doing proper tax planning is to always keep yourself out of all possible grey area situations. I’m aware that the world is messy and that is not always possible – the tax systems are rigid and sometimes maybe even purposefully difficult, but your goal should be to always be “on the clear” with the law – no questions asked. When you do proper planning from the start, that shouldn’t be hard to do. If it feels very difficult, you’ve probably hired the wrong advisors, or your plan is complicated – and it probably shouldn’t be!
With certain business models, you do need to accept that some taxes do need to be paid. Your bar of trying to get “clever” with those should be extremely high – in my opinion the stress and hassle is never worth it, no matter how much money you think you could save. You should always assume that the tax officials are extremely competent in sniffing out all kind of “creative accounting practices”, even if they’re not (often they actually are).
This is not to say that businesses shouldn’t do active tax planning – I’m sure they should, and often those kinds of practices are the only way to keep doing business in very business-hostile countries, like in much of Europe. A lot of the businesses there have already left, or perhaps more often than that, have been killed before being born because after a certain point, people just can’t deal with all that red tape. These countries would still benefit from having businesses, even if they don’t quite pay the “maximum” (business-killing) amount of taxes to the government.
In any case, corporate business strategies are way out of scope here, and we’ll be focusing on practical tax planning – on a personal and small business level, with clearly “above-board” setups that enable you to not have to carry any kind of risk of “discussions” with the tax office!
Let’s get into how the fully and clearly legal tax planning practices might look like.
Moving out of a tax jurisdiction
As probably the first step of implementing any international tax plan, you need to consider how to move out of your current tax jurisdiction. If you are a US citizen, this is actually impossible to do – the US recognizes only one tax residency for their citizens, and that is the US (that doesn’t mean that you wouldn’t get great tax benefits by moving!). I won’t cover US taxes here, as I’m not a US citizen and I don’t have personal experience on the topic, and there are much better other sources of information.
For basically all non-US citizens, you can change your tax residence away from your country of origin. When you move, you need to make sure you move in a way that your current, soon hopefully former, tax authorities agree with. Depending on where you’re moving from, this might not require you to do anything: in many countries, when you move, taxation stops automatically – but don’t count on it!
For your own benefit, you need to make sure your tax obligations do actually stop – in other words, that the tax authorities agree that you’ve officially moved out of their tax jurisdiction and, going forward, won’t be liable for taxes to them. You should be very active with ensuring this, as only thinking you’ve done it can become more than an expensive mistake.
Just the process of having to fight in court about whether you did or didn’t properly move out, can ruin your life. At the end of that process can even be a prison sentence for tax fraud, so you should practice appropriate caution – although things getting that far does require some serious planning mistakes, and it’s very unlikely anyone could carry out an actually criminal level of tax fraud without knowing exactly what they were doing. Honest mistakes can usually be solved with money, and even with the tiniest amount of planning (you’re doing that already), any unclarities are easy to avoid.
There is a scale of how difficult the tax authorities can be.
In the extreme end, there are tax authorities that almost literally treat you as their tax cattle. Probably the worst example is the Australian Tax Office, or ATO for short. Australia is a former penal colony, but ATO doesn’t seem to recognize that “former” part, and treats people moving away from Australia like forced laborers trying to escape.
They may not send people with whips and chains after you, but you should expect a bureaucratic equivalent of that. Unless you make absolutely sure they have no legal way of “getting you”, they have been known to try to find a way to keep you in their tax net.
There are ridiculous examples of this. A very strong rumor is that they’ve even “burned” people for leaving behind “property” such as a surf board. “You left your surfboard here, which obviously indicates that you’re planning to return, and therefore have never really left!”.
If you’re living under this kind of a tyrannical government, be extremely careful with the way you handle your move. The other Commonwealth countries (mainly UK and Canada) seem to also be quite difficult with this. I strongly suggest hiring a professional tax advisor who specializes in people leaving – I’m sure there are many!
In most countries, the tax authorities are reasonable, more or less. As long as you do move factually and not just on paper, they’re not interested in “going after you”. Still, you should assume and plan as you would be a target of a “hostile” tax audit, and make sure you’re doing things in a way that stands up to the heaviest scrutiny.
As I’ve learned on the go, sometimes I’ve had to learn the hard way – fortunately not in the way that would have meant any actual trouble, but let’s just say that just those moments where you even have to think you should have done things differently can be very stressful. The tax codes can be quite misleading, and there’s a lot of completely false information out there.
Often, the “false” information is just a misreading of existing laws and guidelines – relevant in perhaps most cases, but completely irrelevant in your case, as you’re an exception to many otherwise valid rules just by moving abroad. For your own peace of mind, you want to have full understanding of your legal standing, which rules apply, and which ones don’t.
Building this understanding might feel nearly impossible by reading the existing instructions on many official government sites, as they’re understandably not written as “our complete official guide to moving out of our tax net!”. If you “just do your own research”, you’ll have to parse together information from many different sources, which can often seem to be in total conflict with each other.
I highly recommend hiring a competent tax lawyer who is specialized in people planning to exit. Tax lawyers who are not specialized in this, may even do more harm than good. Lawyers should know their own limits and refer you to others when their own knowledge isn’t applicable, but in practice you’re the one who needs to make sure you’re talking to someone who knows exactly what they are talking about.
Warning about tax advisors only focused on one country