What if everyone became location independent?
As you’ve already no doubt noticed, the philosophical basis of this lifestyle is very libertarian. Those who may not care to live free from government control, often settle down and become “happy taxpayers” in whatever location they happen to like – that’s ok, and quite understandable. To each their own.
But what if “everyone” chose to be location independent instead? What would the world look like, and would societies be destroyed because all the taxpayers went elsewhere?
First of all, it has to be noted that not “everyone” will ever choose this lifestyle, as most people value their local (social) environment too highly for that to happen. They will stay at where they’re from, no matter what it costs them – short of war or some other calamity forcing them on the move, the majority will always stay wherever they’re from. The adventurers, the pioneering types have always been a minority, and I don’t expect technological developments to change that.
Let’s play out a thought experiment though – let’s forget about evolutionary facts of life and imagine that everyone did become an adventurer who wanted to move from their home country and never settle down anywhere. Would the world descend into chaos, with societies crumbling down?
For the sake of this thought experiment, let’s ignore cultural aspects of the societies and just focus on practical and economical facts – how would people survive in this new world?
The local businesses (and farms etc.) need people to run them, but let’s also imagine they would adapt and the local jobs would become opportunities for people to find temporary employment wherever they went to.
Let’s also imagine that the governments of the world would recognize that their old funding sources from taxation were permanently drying out, and that they wouldn’t try to fight this new development – after all, everyone is now an adventurer and they would strongly oppose such attempts!
As we touched on lightly in the previous chapters, this still wouldn’t lead to a world with “zero taxes”. The local “consumption taxes” would still remain in place, and the governments would need to adjust to make do without direct exploitation of their tax subjects. You could say that then they would just try to get the same amount of money by raising those consumption taxes, but that would probably mean raising them to well over 100%, driving the now free people elsewhere – therefore, the governments would need to permanently settle to work on significantly lower budgets, one way or the other.
That would have to mean that all “discretionary” spending would fly out the window as the governments simply couldn’t afford any of it anymore. Also, all “pyramid” type social spending would have to stop as the funding would dry out – the pensions from pension funds could still keep going, but they couldn’t be funded beyond that as the consumption taxes would very likely not be enough to keep the current pyramid schemes going.
The consumption taxes would probably be enough to keep only the very basic government services going: internal and external security and maintaining the rule of law.
At first, you might think that this kind of a world would be quite a nightmare, with everyone only out for themselves and if some expensive disaster happened to them, they would effectively be left for dead. Survival would be constantly threatened, with stress levels through the roof!
Then again, these current forms of government-created endless mountains of debt and pyramid schemes are a very recent phenomenon. It used to be, until very recently (roughly 2 generations back), that the “nightmare model” described above was effectively the reality even in the “developed west”, and yet when you look back at history, the nightmare was never there – pretty much on the contrary (if you look a bit farther back, the societies weren’t maybe always that great, but this was before most of the benefits from the industrial society). How is that possible?
The nation and the state
The answer lies in the distinction of two important, separate concepts, that unfortunately have been convoluted so that most people probably never consider these two things as separate:
- The society (nation)
- The government (state)
Nowadays, we’re led to believe – through the marriage of nation & state – that these are effectively the one and the same, but they really are not. The civil society is not the same as the government. Before the “invention of the money printer” (it was more like widespread use of the money printer, not the invention of it, as that happened thousands of years earlier), it used to be that the government had a very small role in the life of the people, and civil society was “in charge” of much more than what it is now.